Fly By Night

| 1 Comment

A lot of things bother me as I read this. I normally bail on a book like this at page 10, but I'm intrigued by this souvenir from the book-sniffing mission on Valencia. And so I plan on reading it all the way through, gathering thoughts on why it's so wretched and how to prevent my own writing from devolving into this quality.

* Slang. Or more precisely, dated slang. Right out of the gate, first sentence, "you've got bats in your belfry." Other words trapped in amber from that era: louse, scram, sporting proposition, in a real jam, in a spot, fierce ("This is fierce," he said. The boy nodded dolefully. "I know it. They're all fierce. The whole place is fierce.")
* Overuse of adjectives and adverbs. Moodily plodded down, grim, rotten dirty trick, swung angrily about, wrapped in gloomy thought, eyes blazing,
* Mundane comparisions. "Eloise laughed a nasty laugh; cruel. It suggested that as a child she probably stuck pins through live butterflies," "a room so bleak it looked like the cell of a penitent monk," "Her eyes, for a second, were like blue water with mist rising over it."
* Overuse of the same words, over and over. Doleful comes up a lot. There's also this doozy: "He chuckled again, even more softly, because this chuckle was a tender chuckle, as chuckles go."
* Just general bad writing: "The Inn of the Sighing Pines is, incredibly, more doleful than its name. Everything about it is perfectly dreadful. In the first place, it is a summer resort. In the second, it is, as its pamphlet says, ultra-refined."
* Confusing writing during action scenes, not sure who does what to whom.
* Inexplicable details, like the fact that Brett could not have a suitcase with him as he flees town, since he goes directly from the Chin Chin club to a man on the run.

Final thought, inspired by this line: "He seemed to Brett more like someone he might read about in a book than an actual man." This book seemed to be a practice run for a real story.

auth=Hatch, Eric
pub=1935

1 Comment

wow, gives me a headache just reading this review.
did you finish it?

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by lz published on May 9, 2009 7:45 AM.

Disgrace was the previous entry in this blog.

Bicycle Library is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.